, , , ,

We Must Never Abandon Identity Politics

Issue Based Campaigns Will Not Work Without Identity Politics

Photo Credit: bvcchurch.ca

The term “identity politics” has been tossed around the past couple years as a pejorative; mostly to equate identity politics with one issue voting. As often happens, leftists and progressives disagree on this point, as I disagree with Progressive Army contributor Mr. Joe Brunoli’s piece Democrats Must Abandon Identity Politics and Run on Actual Policies. The article suggests that identity politics must be abandoned completely and he harkens back to the FDR-Style of progressivism. Those policies hit certain communities especially hard and African Americans took on the brunt of the problem.

“The rationale was the government’s need to protect its investment, and those of white homeowners, against the threat African American neighbors would pose to property values.” – Charles Lane for the Washington Post

Mr. Brunoli also suggests that Alexandria Osacio-Cortez and Senator Bernie Sanders are trying to develop issue-based only campaigns. I personally support Sen. Sanders on most topics, but this was where I feel he dropped the ball during the 2016 campaign and I wasn’t the only one to notice this blind spot. Not directly addressing the issues facing individual communities was a key component missing from his arsenal. As for Congressional hopeful Alexandria Osacio-Cortez, even a perfunctory glance at her platform page is a litany of identity-based political issues that she says she plans on addressing if elected.

It is true that Democrats have a long history of running on identity politics but the problem wasn’t and isn’t this approach. The problem is politicians not following through after securing office. What the Democrats did in the 2016 presidential campaign is what they have been doing for decades; they made a boogeyman of the Republican party and their policies without having a concrete plan or action to replace those problematic stances. Much like the Republicans who rushed to attempt to reverse the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) then couldn’t produce a viable replacement.

A prime example of this from the Democrats was the push for Senator Kamala Harris as a presidential hopeful for 2020. Senator Harris was spouting the same tired talking points from the Democratic Party but they hoped that coming from the mouth of a 1) woman 2) of color would make them easier to swallow.


Related Article: Kamala Harris: Proof that Democrats Still Don’t Understand Progressives


The republic is not only tired of waiting on Democrats to follow through on their campaign promises but is now in dire straits due to this lack of any follow-through on identity policies.

Democrats have a habit of flip-flopping on issues that affect marginalized communities based on whether or not they were politically expedient at the time rather than any true commitment to the ideologies the purport to support. This has caused a lack of trust among longtime democratic supporters and Democrats have been exposed for who they truly are; centrists or rather Republican-lite.

Mr. Brunoli’s suggestion of:

“…getting off the addictive gravy train of corporate cash and it means stopping the vicious cycle of fundraising and spending on lobbyists, consultants, and mass media.”

Is exactly what progressive candidates have done but progressives have seen a dramatic increase in support, not because they abandoned identity politics but because they spoke directly to them. In the aftermath of the 2016 Election, the progressive candidates who are making strides, showing great promise, and winning are largely very connected to the communities they serve. Some are even coming directly from those communities and they are familiar with the needs and the specific needs of those communities. Marginalized and disenfranchised communities may have a common end goal, but the hurdles they face in reaching those goals vary greatly. The needs of the LGBTQI community are not the same needs of farmers. The needs of former coal miners in rural Appalachia are not the same needs as sex workers.

There is no better way to get people to the polls than to show them that they will be voting in their best interest, rather than being forced to choose between the lesser of two evils where their needs are ignored once they have cast their ballots.

We certainly must support candidates that have solid issue-based campaigns but those issues will always need to be viewed through the lens of identity politics in order to be effective.


Written by Pamela Getz

Writer and Activist. Follow Pamela on Twitter @goddesspamela.

Pamela Getz is Editor of International Affairs for Progressive Army and a member of its Editorial Board.


Leave a Reply
  1. Judging people by the color of their skin is the way to electoral victory. Thank you for your vibrant, inclusive article. #fenceJumperAmericans #basketBallAmericans #vaginalAmericans #peterPufferAmericans

  2. “Vote for me because I’m _____ like you” has given us several generations of politicians who get elected either on ethnicity, religion or gender, who end up betraying the people who voted based on their identity–whatever it is. I realize corrupt politicians use this tactic because it works, but we should all realize by now that it is a con job. Bernie Sanders did not generate a huge following because he was a cranky, old Jewish guy: it was because of the specific programs that he advocates that resonate with a large part of the electorate. How many women have been elected to Congress or some other post, whose actual stand on issues was inimical to women’s rights? Barack Obama won by getting out the African American vote; and while he was the best choice by far in both 2008 and 2012, he gave a slap on the wrist to the banksters, did very little to help the working poor, delivered a windfall to the Insurance industry instead of Universal Health Care, nothing at all to help African Americans and by and large cozied up to the 1% and Military-Industrial-Media Complex rather than delivering the “Hope and Change” he promised us. So no, identity politics has not been good for the majority of Americans, just for the oligarchs whom the politicians actually work for. Time for something different.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Democrats Must Abandon Identity Politics and Run on Actual Policies

We Must Never Abandon Identity Politics